Xbox 360 Games Similar to Red Dead Redemption

No perfect clone, but these share DNA:

Open World + Narrative

• Grand Theft Auto IV: Liberty City, Niko's story, weighty physics, moral choices.
• Fallout 3: Post-apocalyptic DC, VATS, exploration, faction reputation.
• The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion: Fantasy open world, radiant quests, deep systems.

Western Setting + Action

• Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood: Prequel, dual protagonists, cover shooting, duels.
• Gun (2005): Neversoft, stylized West, quick-draw mechanic, short but dense.

Character-Driven Story

• Alan Wake: Psychological thriller, light combat, episodic, superb writing.
• Mass Effect 2: Sci-fi, squad loyalty missions, choices matter, 10/10 characters.

True Successor

Red Dead Redemption 2 (Xbox One/Series/PS4/PC) — prequel, vastly deeper systems, 60+ hour story, same universe. Play this.