The Sims (GameCube) Requires a 59-Block Memory Card, Not 60
The Sims on GameCube only saves to an official 59-block (512 KB) Memory Card. Third-party "60-block" cards (often marketed as 251/1019 blocks = 2MB/8MB) will not be recognized by the game.
Why This Happens
The game's save routine checks for the exact official Nintendo 59-block format (specific File ID and checksum structure).
Third-party high-capacity cards use different banking and addressing schemes. The game reads them as "Corrupted" or "No Card."
Solutions
Buy an official Nintendo 59-block card (DOL-008): Grey with the "Nintendo GameCube" logo. Typically $10–$20 used. Most reliable option.
Use a 251-block official card (DOL-014): Black, labeled "251 Blocks." Works because it's essentially four 59-block banks; the game uses the first bank.
Softmod + SD Gecko / GCLoader: Redirect saves to an SD card via homebrew. Requires a modded GameCube or Wii.
Don't Waste Money On
Generic "60/128/256/1019 block" cards (Mad Catz, Nyko, Performance, unbranded). They work for other games, but not The Sims.
Formatting in the Wii Menu—it doesn't change the card's hardware ID.
Get the grey 59-block card. It's the only guarantee.