Home >> Internet Games >> Nintendo Wii

Price Guide: New Super Mario Bros. Wii (Used) — 2024 Market Values

New (sealed) copies are virtually extinct. Nintendo stopped printing ~2012. Any "New" listing is likely resealed or old store stock at collector prices ($150–$300+). You are buying **used**.

Current Market Prices (USD, 2024, Loose vs Complete)

Condition	Price Range	Notes
Loose Disc Only	$8 – $15	Disc may have scratches; test before buying.
Disc + Case + Cover Art	$15 – $25	Standard "Complete in Box" (CIB).
CIB + Manual + Inserts	$25 – $40	Collector condition.
Sealed (VGA/WATA Graded)	$200 – $500+	Speculator market. Not for playing.

Where to Buy (Best Value → Worst)

Local: Facebook Marketplace / OfferUp / Craigslist — Meet, test in your Wii, cash, no shipping. Often $10–$20 CIB.
Local Game Stores (Non-GameStop) — Usually $15–$25 CIB, 30-day warranty.
eBay — Filter "US Only," "Free Returns," Seller >99%. Search "New Super Mario Bros Wii CIB". Sniped auctions can hit $12.
Mercari — Buyer protection, easy returns. Prices similar to eBay.
GameStop (Online/Store) — "Pre-Owned" ~$20–$30. 7-day return. Often disc-only priced same as CIB.
Amazon (Third Party) — Often overpriced ($30+). Avoid.

Buying Checklist

**Disc:** Hold to light. No deep radial scratches (circular = drive damage). Minor radial OK.
**Case:** Original Wii keep case (clear/white spine). Not generic DVD case.
**Manual:** 20+ pages, color. Reproductions exist (flimsy paper).
**Region:** NTSC-U (USA) vs PAL (EUR) vs NTSC-J. **Must match your Wii region** (unless homebrew region-free).

Digital Alternative

Wii U eShop (Closed March 2023) — No longer purchasable. If you bought it, redownload on Wii U (Wii Mode).

Recommendation: Buy **Disc + Case + Manual** locally for **$15–$20**. Test it. Keep forever. It's a masterpiece.

Nintendo Wii