Valuing 50 PS2 Games in Average Condition: Identify Needles in the Haystack First

Impossible to estimate without a title list. Value hinges on specifics.

What Drives Price

• Rarity: Rule of Rose, Kuon, .hack//Quarantine = $100s; Madden 2005 = $2
• Completeness: Case + manual + disc = 2–5× loose disc value
• Condition: "Average" = light scratches, maybe minor case wear — buyers discount heavily
• Demand: Cult classics (Psychonauts, Okami) > forgotten shovelware

How to Get Real Numbers

1. List every title (spreadsheet: Title | Condition | Complete?)
2. Check PriceCharting.com, eBay sold listings, GameValueNow
3. Sort: high‑value outliers vs. bulk fodder

Selling Strategies

• Individual: Max return, high effort, fees/shipping each
• Curated lots: Group by genre/series, 5–10 per lot
• Bulk lot: Fastest, lowest $/game — "50 PS2 games, mixed condition"
• Trade‑in (GameStop, etc.): Convenience tax — expect 30–50% of private sale value

One Suikoden II or Persona 3 FES could exceed the rest combined. Identify the needles in the haystack first.