Can You Trade a Nintendo DS for a DSi XL at GameStop? No—Here's Why

Short answer: GameStop does not accept original Nintendo DS (Phat) or DS Lite trade-ins toward a DSi XL. The original DS models are too old for their current trade-in program.

Your Alternatives

• Buy a used DSi XL outright. GameStop sells refurbished units with a warranty—often $60–$90 depending on condition.
• Sell your DS privately. eBay, Facebook Marketplace, or a local pawn shop will pay cash. A working DS Lite with charger fetches $25–$45; original "Phat" DS slightly less.
• Check local independent game stores. Some have more flexible trade policies or buy outright for cash.

Before You Sell or Trade

Ensure the system powers on, both screens work (no dead pixels or lines), hinge is intact (for Lite), and you include the charger. A complete, functional unit always commands more—whether trading or selling.