Neither is objectively "better"—the right choice depends on your priorities. Both launched Nov 2013, ~117M (PS4) vs ~58M (Xbox One) sold. Here's a 2024 perspective:
| Factor | Xbox One (S/X) | PS4 (Slim/Pro) |
|---|---|---|
| Exclusive Games | Halo, Gears, Forza, Starfield (PC/Xbox), Fable (upcoming) | God of War, Spider-Man, Horizon, Uncharted, TLOU, Ghost of Tsushima, Bloodborne, Ratchet & Clank, Returnal, Demon's Souls |
| Subscription Value | Game Pass Ultimate ($16.99/mo): Day-one 1st party, EA Play, PC, Cloud, 300+ games | PS Plus Extra/Premium ($14.99/$17.99): Large catalog, no day-one 1st party, game trials, classics streaming |
| Backward Compatibility | Excellent: 600+ Xbox 360/OG Xbox games, auto HDR, FPS Boost, 4K patches | Limited: PS1/PS2/PS3 via streaming only (Premium); PS4 games native |
| Controller | Offset sticks, textured triggers, AA batteries/rechargeable, Elite Series 2 (pro) | Symmetrical sticks, adaptive triggers (DualSense on PS5 only), light bar, touchpad, internal battery |
| Media / Apps | Dolby Vision/Atmos, UHD Blu-ray (S/X), all major apps | UHD Blu-ray (Pro only), Dolby Atmos (no Vision), all major apps |
| VR | None | PS VR (PS4), PS VR2 (PS5 only) |
| Cross-Play | Full support | Full support |
| Current Price (Used) | Xbox One S: $150–$200; X: $250–$300 | PS4 Slim: $180–$230; Pro: $280–$350 |
Both are obsolete for new releases (2024+ games target Series X|S/PS5/PC). Buying used last-gen is for back-catalog value only.