Backward Compatible PS3 (Fat) vs. Newer Console: 2024 Buying Guide

This comparison assumes "PS3 that plays PS2 games" = Launch "Fat" Models (CECHA/B/C/E - 20/60/80GB Hardware EE+GS or 80GB Software EMU) vs. a modern console (PS4/PS5/Switch/Xbox Series).

Option A: Backward Compatible PS3 Fat (CECHA/B/C/E)

Pros

• Native PS2/PS1 Hardware: Best possible compatibility (98%+), no emulation artifacts, pressure-sensitive buttons work (needed for MGS3, GT4, Ace Combat).
• PS3 Library: Plays all PS3 games.
• Blu-ray / SACD / CD: Full media playback.
• Linux / OtherOS (Pre-3.21 FW): Historical curiosity.
• CFW/HEN Potential: NAND/NOR flashers allow permanent Custom Firmware (evilnat, rebug) → Homebrew, PS2 Classics placeholder, ISO mounting, fan control, region free.

Cons

• YLOD Risk: Lead-free BGA solder (Cell/RSX) fatigues with thermal cycles. 60GB/20GB highest risk. Reball (BGA rework) costs $100-150; lasts 2-5 years.
• Power Draw: 180-200W idle/game. Loud fans.
• Size/Weight: 5 kg, huge footprint.
• No Modern Services: No PSN store (closed 2021), no streaming apps, no Discord, no modern TLS certs (web browser broken).
• Price: Working CECHA/B (60/20GB) $250-400+; CECHC/E (80GB) $180-250.

Option B: Modern Console (PS5 / Xbox Series X / Switch)

Pros

• Current Games: Access to 2013-2024 library.
• Performance: 4K/60-120fps, SSD loading, Ray Tracing.
• Services: Active online, stores, cloud saves, Game Pass/PS Plus.
• Reliability: 1-3 year warranty, modern lead-free solder improved.
• Backward Compat (Partial): PS5 plays ~99% PS4. Xbox Series plays select OG/360 titles (enhanced). Switch: N64/GC/NES/SNES/GB/GBA/N64 via NSO.

Cons

• No Native PS2/PS3: PS3 games stream-only (PS Plus Premium, latency/compression). PS2 classics: limited curated ports (PS4/PS5 store).
• Cost: $300-500+.

Decision Matrix

Pro Tip: A PS3 Slim/Super Slim (CECH-2000/3000/4000) with HEN/CFW + a decent PC running PCSX2 (PS2 emulator) is cheaper, more reliable, and higher fidelity (4K, widescreen hacks, texture filtering) than a dying Fat PS3.